INTERVIEW FOR CSE 2019
All ForumIAS members selected for CSE 2019 Personality Test must submit their details and DAF and register below to receive further instructions and guidance from ForumIAS. Click here to register now
INTERVIEW 2020 CHANNEL
ForumIAS Channel for Interview Preparation is now Active! Please join the channel by clicking here
We are hiring!

A polite discussion on why Bhojpuri isn't an 8th schedule language.

This is an invitation to all the Bhojpuri speakers to share their feelings about the issue. Plz remain civil if u have something to say.

I am a native Bhojpuri speaker. I don't claim any scholarly knowledge of the language, because of an upbringing in a multicultural environment, but I know one thing for sure that I am a purist at spoken Bhojpuri.

One hears on n off that there is some political intention of declaring it as 8th sch language, but it never comes to fruition. Meanwhile mathili speakers have the leisure of not preparing for the optional.so much so, Bhojpuri doesn't even have the recognition in Bihar PCs, let alone upsc.

It breaks my heart to see that our beautiful language spoken by millions n millions across the country doesn't even have the pleasure of recognition, forget about promotion. No recognition amounts to disrespect to it's speakers. Real Bhojpuri is way different from the crass shit they sell as Bhojpuri in movies. It borrows a lot from Urdu, nepali n sometimes is quite akin to Bengali.

What do you guys think?? Am I missing something when i think it's an independent tongue worthy of recognition. Or is it's neglect justified?



«1345678

Comments

  • edited December 2017
    People and politics are the two inter-related reasons.

    1. Lack of regional outlook among Bhojpuri speakers. A contributing factor is that Bhojpuri speakers don't feel culturally threatened. Moreover casteism and communalism keeps people divided - former being more prominent than the latter.

    2. Politics only responds to one thing - electoral threat. And language has never been a strong enough element to mobilise people in these regions. And people are lethargic, non-confrontational, non-enterprising. So there is nothing that will push the politics of the region to address regional concerns.

    I think the main reason is an attitude problem - problem because regionalism is mainstream now, so lack of regionalism is a disabling thing. It's not just about recognising a language. Bhojpuri speaking areas are likely to remain the most backward area in India for a long time. Politics can enable a turn-around. But for that politics itself needs a turn-around.

    and perhaps language is not the most critical oncern of the region. At least it is not perceived as being immediately related to economic backwardness.
  • bhojpuri 8 schedule main add ho jati but Hindi language pr impact hoga bcoz dono kafi same ho jaige islay add nahi hogi asa khna tha bjp MPs ka last session main let's see ..
  • edited December 2017
    भोजपुरी में शिष्ट साहित्य का अभाव है। लोक साहित्य प्रचुर होने से हम किसी बोली को भाषा का दर्जा नहीं दे सकते। साथ ही किसी भी औपचारिक कार्य में भोजपुरी का प्रयोग नहीं होता। मसलन, आरा में भी शादी के निमंत्रण पत्र मानक हिंदी में छपते हैं, भोजपुरी में नहीं। अतः यह एक बोली ही है, भाषा नहीं।
  • lack of script..kaithi script use hota hai waise..
    strong hindi lobby...
    no strong political will & effort..
    neglect by native speakers..
    bhojpuri bolna log kafi log ko ajeeb lagta h..
    mai kabhi acchi zagah bhojpuri bolne walo ko b is bhasha me baat krte nhi dekha h..
  • image Haryanvi for 8th schedule!
  • Bhojpuri is a dialect. Maithili is a language, AFAIK
  • image Haryanvi for 8th schedule!
    hat ja tau pacche ne
  • My intention was not against maithili, I wanted to convey that it's much easier to write an optional paper that is ur own language, be it maithili or any other 8th sch language n I wish Bhojpuri had this recognition at least at the state pcs.

    Jahan tak maine suna Hai the by n large reason for non inclusion for Bhojpuri is lack of literature. Agar ye reason Hai toh fir Kai local universities mein Bhojpuri mein b.a. /m.a. kyu offer karte hain. Kucch toh literature hoga iska Matlab.
  • My intention was not against maithili, I wanted to convey that it's much easier to write an optional paper that is ur own language, be it maithili or any other 8th sch language n I wish Bhojpuri had this recognition at least at the state pcs.

    Jahan tak maine suna Hai the by n large reason for non inclusion for Bhojpuri is lack of literature. Agar ye reason Hai toh fir Kai local universities mein Bhojpuri mein b.a. /m.a. kyu offer karte hain. Kucch toh literature hoga iska Matlab.
    Sirf lok sahitya hai...MATLAB byah gauna Tilak mein Gaye Jane wale geet...sohar...etc...bhikhari Thakur ke kuch pad hai...bass.. waise Mauritius mein Bhojpuri mein likha Jara hai...
  • Besides, it is indeed recognised as a language in other countries like Mauritius n carib.
Sign In or Join to comment.

Welcome!

We are a secret self-moderated community for Civil Services preparation. Feel free to join, start a discussion, answer a question or just to say Thank you.

Just dont spread the word ;)

Sign in or join with Facebook or Google